T20 World Cup: Clinical Scotland and injury scare ruin Italy's dream debut

Italy’s first-ever T20 World Cup game was always going to feel special. New colours on the big stage, a fresh anthem in the air, and that debut-day buzz of “we’ve finally made it.” Eden Gardens in Kolkata was the perfect setting too, the kind of venue where even the toss feels like a moment.

For Italy, history arrived the second Wayne Madsen walked out for the toss, and went on to even win it for his side.

SCO vs ITA, T20 World Cup: Highlights | Scorecard

However, what followed was a quick reminder that the World Cup can be an unforgiving place to learn.

Italy’s debut ended in a 73-run defeat, bowled out for 134 in 16.4 overs while chasing Scotland’s 207. The evening also carried an added blow, with Madsen suffering a shoulder dislocation that could potentially rule him out for the rest of the tournament. Italy had their firsts, but Scotland made sure the scoreboard told the louder story.

Italy had walked in with confidence. Madsen spoke at the toss about wanting a memorable campaign and backing their bowling strength. This wasn’t a side just happy to show up. The problem was Scotland didn’t arrive to play along. They arrived to take control, and they did it with calm sharpness.

Even in defeat, Italy will take pride from four bowlers picking up their first World Cup wickets. Ben Manenti hitting a half-century.

Those are the small milestones that matter. But the bigger picture was simple: Scotland were cleaner, stronger, and more ruthless in the key moments.

How Scotland breached the 200-run mark

There was a fun World Cup twist tucked inside Scotland’s dominance.

In a tournament where most expected the 200-run mark to be crossed first by India, Pakistan, England or the West Indies, it was Scotland who got there before anyone else.

George Munsey looked in scary touch, racing to 85 and playing like a man who had decided Eden Gardens was his personal playground. Italy did get a significant moment when Grant Stewart removed him, a wicket that will go down as one of Italy’s first major scalps at a World Cup. But Scotland didn’t slow down after that, because Michael Leask made sure the ending was loud. The final over went for 22 runs, and suddenly Italy weren’t chasing “a big total,” they were chasing a mountain.

How Italy's 208 chase panned out

Italy’s reply began with the kind of moment that makes you sigh, Justin Mosca gone first ball, a blunt welcome to World Cup cricket.

But almost immediately, Italy gave everyone a reminder that debutants can have bite too. Will Smuts struck Italy’s first-ever World Cup six, and then came an over that briefly lit up the evening. Smuts went 6,4,6 off the first three balls, and Mosca finished it with a towering six of his own, giving the crowd and the few Italy fans a moment to cheer for.

Smuts was dismissed in the very next over, and from there Scotland’s control grew stronger. The fielding was sharp, the catching was clean, and the bowlers gave nothing away for free. Italy kept trying to find a way back in, but Scotland were already dictating the rhythm of the chase.

Manenti brothers give Italy a highlight reel

If Italy fans needed one phase to hold on to from this debut, it was the Manenti brothers. Harry and Ben stitched together a blazing 73-run partnership for the fourth wicket, and for a while they made the chase feel interesting again. Harry played the aggressor, taking on the bowlers and finding boundaries, while Ben was the steady presence, rotating strike and picking gaps to make sure Italy didn’t lose shape completely.

It was one of those stands that makes you think Italy might be new here, but they are not out of place. They pushed Italy past 100 by the 12th over, and suddenly Scotland had to work again. But the breakthrough arrived in the 13th over, Harry was dismissed, and despite Ben having pushed on after his half-century, it was clear that the Manenti momentum had run its course.

How Michael Leask ruined Italy's debut

If one name kept showing up at the wrong time for Italy, it was Michael Leask. He had already helped Scotland push beyond 200 with that brutal finish, and then he came back with the ball to rip through Italy’s chase, finishing with a superb 4/17.

Ben Manenti still managed his own slice of history, becoming Italy’s first-ever World Cup half-centurion with a 29-ball fifty, but even that moment was brief as he was dismissed two balls later. Without Wayne Madsen able to take the crease because of his shoulder injury, Italy simply ran out of answers, and the innings folded at 134.

Italy’s debut wasn’t perfect, far from it, but it wasn’t empty either. There were firsts, there were flashes, and there was the Manenti brothers’ stand that showed Italy can compete in patches. Scotland, though, were simply too polished for the Gli Azzuri.

T20 World Cup | T20 World Cup Schedule | T20 World Cup Points Table | T20 World Cup Videos | Cricket News | Live Score