Butchers of Sopore and Birmingham

Nine years of calm before icy storm

Kashmir turns crimson with blood of Pandits

AN UN-ISLAMIC KIDNAPPING AND CHAOS IN THE VALLEY

The illusion of azaadi and Kashmir’s historic deception

How Pak's terror policy evolved in Kashmir

Birth of social media jihadists, death of Article-370

Operation Sindoor: When Indian missiles rained on Pak terror parade

<div class='ite_mg_banner ads__container'><div class='it_mg_bnrBox'><div class='ite_bnr_cont'><div class='ite_cont_dtl'> <h4>Subscribe to India Today Print + Digital. Your First Month Is On Us. <span class='bold_text'> ₹299/month</span> thereafter. Cancel anytime.</h4><a href='https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.dev?url=https%3A%2F%2Fsubscriptions.intoday.in%2Findiatoday%3Futm_source%3Dtop-web-banner ' class='ite_subscribe_btn origin_conscent_url' target='_blank'>SUBSCRIBE</a></div></div></div></div>

US Election coverage

India

World

NewsMo

Fact Check

Programmes

Match Schedule

Teams

Player Stats

Match Report

LIVE SCORES

<div class="itg-mosimage"><amp-img src="https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.dev?url=https%3A%2F%2Fakm-img-a-in.tosshub.com%2Fsites%2Fmedia2%2Findiatoday%2Fimages%2Fstories%2F1998August%2Fmaharashtra-1_082312122811.gif" alt="" height="425" width="650" class="" layout="responsive"></amp-img><p>It's early days yet but the signs are evident.</p><p>When Maharashtra Finance Minister Mahadev Shivankar recently wrote to Chief Minister Manohar Joshi about the deteriorating condition of the state's finances, he was only endorsing the fears expressed by bureaucrats: that the BJP-Shiv Sena Government's populist policies were pushing the state close to a debt trap.<br><br>Last month, for instance, Chief Secretary P. Subrahmanyam had an unusual duty to perform. He had to remind the Government that there was no cabinet note for the promised sanction of Rs 143 crore as relief to cotton farmers.</p><p>"Where would the money be drawn from?" he asked. While the money was paid out, who will eventually pick up the tab remains a mystery. Given the state of Maharashtra's finances, there would either have to be a cut in the Plan, to which the Government was not agreeable, or add to the deficit of Rs 7,748.39 crore.<br><br>Senior officials say that such instances of the Sena-BJP Government's "spend now, think later" syndrome abound.</p><p>Indeed, the feeling is that the farmers should count themselves lucky since they received the money. Several other grand projects announced by the Government in its three-year tenure are in limbo simply because the state has no funds to get on with them.</p><p>One such project is the grandiose Krishna Valley Irrigation Scheme announced in 1994, envisaging a cost of Rs 7,100 crore. The Government was supposed to have pumped in Rs 3,500 crore over a period of five years.</p><div class="itemcenter"><amp-iframe height="62" title="" width="320" sandbox="allow-forms allow-scripts allow-same-origin allow-popups allow-top-navigation allow-top-navigation-by-user-activation" allowfullscreen src="https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.dev?url=https%3A%2F%2Fakm-img-a-in.tosshub.com%2Fsites%2Findiatoday%2Fbanner%2Fpreferred-source-new.html%3Fv%3D1.014%5Cu0026native%3D1" class="mrBt15 preferred-source-banner"> </amp-iframe></div></p><p>In the first three years, it was able to provide a budgetary support of Rs 975 crore, this year the provision has been nil. Yet, that hasn't stopped it from announcing the Godavari and Tapti schemes.<br><br>Better still, it has stood guarantee to various state departments which have borrowed huge sums for power, irrigation and housing projects, expressways, flyovers and water supply schemes. This, without calculating how it would pay the interest, let alone repay the principal amounts.</p><p>Take the case of the newly floated Maharashtra State Road Development Corporation for which the Government plans to borrow around Rs 2,000 crore. The interest alone would be over Rs 200 crore per year while the revenue is expected to be around Rs 130 crore.</p><p>The plan is to raise the shortfall through land sale. But what is the guarantee that this will materialise given the recession in the real-estate market? Moreover, how will it source funds for the recurring years?</p><p>"You can't fund a long-term project with short-term borrowings or recurring expenses with a one-time sale of assets," says a principal secretary in the state secretariat. "The answer lies in increasing revenue," offers a senior secretary, "but that does not seem to be the Government's priority."<br></p><table><tbody><tr><td> <b>GONE BUST</b></td></tr><tr><td><ul><li>Of every rupee the state Government earns, 49.16 paise goes towards paying salaries and servicing debt. In relation to revenue earned, the figure is 75.23 paise. This year, Rs 4,400 crore will have to be borrowed to meet these ends.</li></ul><ul><li>As a result, there has been a fall in spending on development. Capital expenditure from borrowings has fallen from 90 per cent of fiscal deficit last year to 35 per cent. Consumption expenditure as a per cent of total expenditure has risen from 21.8 per cent last year to 28.1 per cent and gross capital formation has fallen from 18.9 per cent to 13.1 per cent.</li></ul><ul><li>The state is borrowing much more just to pay interest. The figure: Rs 4,070 crore, up from Rs 1,915 crore last year. Total debt: Rs 30,999 crore, up from Rs 16,020 crore in 1995-96. In other words, the state is walking into a debt trap.</li></ul></td></tr></tbody></table></p><p>Eighteen months ago, the Revenue Department mooted that the Government's land lease rates for high-value areas like Cuffe Parade, Hill Road,Bandra and Matheran be raised.</p><p>But Finance Department officials have sat over it, ostensibly because they have not been able to decide on which inflation index to use to calculate the new lease rates.</p><p>The result: the Government earns a paltry Rs 50,000 as annual lease revenue from Matheran when hotels in the hill station make 10 times that amount in a month.</p><p>The same is the case with Cuffe Parade where the residents of flats costing crores of rupees pay a nominal revenue fixed on an ad hoc basis in the '70s.</p><p>There have been occasions when the Government has taken revenue-boosting decisions, but they have arrived too late in the day.</p><p>In May 1997, after four years of dithering, the Government revised bus ticket rates by 25 per cent amid a chorus of protests.</p><p>Within three months, fuel rates were hiked and the revenue increase was wiped out by the Rs 95-crore diesel bill.</p><p>Consequently, the Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation's net loss went up from -Rs113.43 lakh to Rs 13,838.38 lakh in 1996-97. The Maharashtra State Electricity Board (MSEB) is facing a similar situation due to the Government's inability to raise revenue and cut losses.<br><br>The latest report on state public-sector enterprises (PSE) shows their profits dropped from Rs 416.90 crore to Rs 150.49 crore in 1996-97.<br><br>Strangely, the Government has not woken up to the gravity of the situation. Though Shivankar admits it is "worsening", he is chary of revealing the details of his letter, which was presented at the state BJP meeting in Panvel.</p><p>State Finance Secretary R. Budhiraja too is circumspect. "This is a difficult year," he says, "particularly in the light of the Fifth Pay Commission recommendations." This entails an arrears bill of Rs 8,000 crore and a recurring annual expense of Rs 5,000 crore. A liability clearly beyond the state's paying capacity.<br><br>The Government is pinning its hopes on the 11th Finance Commission to wriggle out of the crisis. "We would like to get the power to tax the service sector directly," says Budhiraja. "Unless we start tapping it, there is bound to be trouble as there is a limit to how much we can tax the manufacturing sector."</p><p>On his part, Shivankar is planning to follow Union Finance Minister Yashwant Sinha's footsteps. "We want to announce a Samadhan scheme for pending sales tax cases in which Rs2,500 crore is stuck," he says. "This should help us out for now."<br><br>That apart, there is no real effort to seek a long-term solution for the state's dwindling finances. For instance, there is no talk of cutting losses, even if the decision is political. Of the 31 state milk schemes, 24 are in the red with losses totalling over Rs 66.5 crore.</p><p>Yet, the Government is raising procurement prices without a price hike. Also myopic is the freeze on the prices of five essential commodities- rice, wheat, sugar, edible oil and turdal - which the Government subsidises for the poor.</p><p>Instead of pegging the prices at a lower differential, it has frozen the prices, leading to a rising outflow, pegged at Rs 217 crore this year. The Government's much-vaunted programme to privatise PSEs is also stuck in a quagmire of counter pressures from trade unions and bidders who are looking to strip state assets cheaply.</p><p>Despite a keen interest shown by the private sector, there is no policy that could help generate huge revenues from its high-worth assets. Even non-controversial proposals with revenue potential are being ignored. Telecom companies have been asking the Government to lease facilities on the MSEB network or through water supply veins to carry voice and data.</p><p>This could generate good income. But there has been no response from the Government. "For a cabinet split on caste, party and regional lines, all these are too progressive even to consider," admits a senior BJP member.</p><p>Of course, there is some consolation in the fact that Maharashtra is not as badly placed as some other states. But given the Government's penchant for grandiose schemes, the ground is certainly slipping. Like the classic Lewis Caroll scenario, it will take all the running it can do for the Government to stay in the same place. To get anywhere, it will have to run twice as fast. <br></p><div id="tab-link-wrapper-plugin"><div class="authors__container"><div class="authors__by"><div class="authlable">Published By: </div><div class="authdetaisl">AtMigration </div></div><div class="published__on"><div class="authlable">Published On: </div><div class="authdetaisl">Aug 24, 1998</div></div></div><div class="sendros">--- ENDS ---</div></div></div>

states

States

<div class="itg-mosimage"><div class="itgimage"><img  title=""  class="" alt="" src="https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.dev?url=https%3A%2F%2Fakm-img-a-in.tosshub.com%2Fsites%2Fmedia2%2Findiatoday%2Fimages%2Fstories%2F1998August%2Fmaharashtra-1_082312122811.gif" loading="lazy" /></div><p>It's early days yet but the signs are evident.</p><p>When Maharashtra Finance Minister Mahadev Shivankar recently wrote to Chief Minister Manohar Joshi about the deteriorating condition of the state's finances, he was only endorsing the fears expressed by bureaucrats: that the BJP-Shiv Sena Government's populist policies were pushing the state close to a debt trap.<br><br>Last month, for instance, Chief Secretary P. Subrahmanyam had an unusual duty to perform. He had to remind the Government that there was no cabinet note for the promised sanction of Rs 143 crore as relief to cotton farmers.</p><p>"Where would the money be drawn from?" he asked. While the money was paid out, who will eventually pick up the tab remains a mystery. Given the state of Maharashtra's finances, there would either have to be a cut in the Plan, to which the Government was not agreeable, or add to the deficit of Rs 7,748.39 crore.<br><br>Senior officials say that such instances of the Sena-BJP Government's "spend now, think later" syndrome abound.</p><p>Indeed, the feeling is that the farmers should count themselves lucky since they received the money. Several other grand projects announced by the Government in its three-year tenure are in limbo simply because the state has no funds to get on with them.</p><p>One such project is the grandiose Krishna Valley Irrigation Scheme announced in 1994, envisaging a cost of Rs 7,100 crore. The Government was supposed to have pumped in Rs 3,500 crore over a period of five years.</p><div class="itemcenter"><iframe scrolling="no" allowfullscreen="" frameborder="0" width="100%" height="62" awidth="320" aheight="62" amplayout="fixed" src="https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.dev?url=https%3A%2F%2Fakm-img-a-in.tosshub.com%2Fsites%2Findiatoday%2Fbanner%2Fpreferred-source-new.html%3Fv%3D1.014" class="preferred-source-banner" loading="lazy"></iframe></div><style>.preferred-source-banner{  margin-top: 10px; margin-bottom:10px;}</style></p><p>In the first three years, it was able to provide a budgetary support of Rs 975 crore, this year the provision has been nil. Yet, that hasn't stopped it from announcing the Godavari and Tapti schemes.<br><br>Better still, it has stood guarantee to various state departments which have borrowed huge sums for power, irrigation and housing projects, expressways, flyovers and water supply schemes. This, without calculating how it would pay the interest, let alone repay the principal amounts.</p><p>Take the case of the newly floated Maharashtra State Road Development Corporation for which the Government plans to borrow around Rs 2,000 crore. The interest alone would be over Rs 200 crore per year while the revenue is expected to be around Rs 130 crore.</p><p>The plan is to raise the shortfall through land sale. But what is the guarantee that this will materialise given the recession in the real-estate market? Moreover, how will it source funds for the recurring years?</p><p>"You can't fund a long-term project with short-term borrowings or recurring expenses with a one-time sale of assets," says a principal secretary in the state secretariat. "The answer lies in increasing revenue," offers a senior secretary, "but that does not seem to be the Government's priority."<br></p><table style="background-color: rgb(229, 229, 229); margin-left: 8px;" align="right" border="1" cellpadding="3" cellspacing="3" height="374" width="277"><tbody><tr align="center"><td> <b style="color: rgb(204, 0, 0);">GONE BUST</b></td></tr><tr><td><ul><li>Of every rupee the state Government earns, 49.16 paise goes towards paying salaries and servicing debt. In relation to revenue earned, the figure is 75.23 paise. This year, Rs 4,400 crore will have to be borrowed to meet these ends.</li></ul><ul><li>As a result, there has been a fall in spending on development. Capital expenditure from borrowings has fallen from 90 per cent of fiscal deficit last year to 35 per cent. Consumption expenditure as a per cent of total expenditure has risen from 21.8 per cent last year to 28.1 per cent and gross capital formation has fallen from 18.9 per cent to 13.1 per cent.</li></ul><ul><li>The state is borrowing much more just to pay interest. The figure: Rs 4,070 crore, up from Rs 1,915 crore last year. Total debt: Rs 30,999 crore, up from Rs 16,020 crore in 1995-96. In other words, the state is walking into a debt trap.</li></ul></td></tr></tbody></table></p><p>Eighteen months ago, the Revenue Department mooted that the Government's land lease rates for high-value areas like Cuffe Parade, Hill Road,Bandra and Matheran be raised.</p><p>But Finance Department officials have sat over it, ostensibly because they have not been able to decide on which inflation index to use to calculate the new lease rates.</p><p>The result: the Government earns a paltry Rs 50,000 as annual lease revenue from Matheran when hotels in the hill station make 10 times that amount in a month.</p><p>The same is the case with Cuffe Parade where the residents of flats costing crores of rupees pay a nominal revenue fixed on an ad hoc basis in the '70s.</p><p>There have been occasions when the Government has taken revenue-boosting decisions, but they have arrived too late in the day.</p><p>In May 1997, after four years of dithering, the Government revised bus ticket rates by 25 per cent amid a chorus of protests.</p><p>Within three months, fuel rates were hiked and the revenue increase was wiped out by the Rs 95-crore diesel bill.</p><p>Consequently, the Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation's net loss went up from -Rs113.43 lakh to Rs 13,838.38 lakh in 1996-97. The Maharashtra State Electricity Board (MSEB) is facing a similar situation due to the Government's inability to raise revenue and cut losses.<br><br>The latest report on state public-sector enterprises (PSE) shows their profits dropped from Rs 416.90 crore to Rs 150.49 crore in 1996-97.<br><br>Strangely, the Government has not woken up to the gravity of the situation. Though Shivankar admits it is "worsening", he is chary of revealing the details of his letter, which was presented at the state BJP meeting in Panvel.</p><p>State Finance Secretary R. Budhiraja too is circumspect. "This is a difficult year," he says, "particularly in the light of the Fifth Pay Commission recommendations." This entails an arrears bill of Rs 8,000 crore and a recurring annual expense of Rs 5,000 crore. A liability clearly beyond the state's paying capacity.<br><br>The Government is pinning its hopes on the 11th Finance Commission to wriggle out of the crisis. "We would like to get the power to tax the service sector directly," says Budhiraja. "Unless we start tapping it, there is bound to be trouble as there is a limit to how much we can tax the manufacturing sector."</p><p>On his part, Shivankar is planning to follow Union Finance Minister Yashwant Sinha's footsteps. "We want to announce a Samadhan scheme for pending sales tax cases in which Rs2,500 crore is stuck," he says. "This should help us out for now."<br><br>That apart, there is no real effort to seek a long-term solution for the state's dwindling finances. For instance, there is no talk of cutting losses, even if the decision is political. Of the 31 state milk schemes, 24 are in the red with losses totalling over Rs 66.5 crore.</p><p>Yet, the Government is raising procurement prices without a price hike. Also myopic is the freeze on the prices of five essential commodities- rice, wheat, sugar, edible oil and turdal - which the Government subsidises for the poor.</p><p>Instead of pegging the prices at a lower differential, it has frozen the prices, leading to a rising outflow, pegged at Rs 217 crore this year. The Government's much-vaunted programme to privatise PSEs is also stuck in a quagmire of counter pressures from trade unions and bidders who are looking to strip state assets cheaply.</p><p>Despite a keen interest shown by the private sector, there is no policy that could help generate huge revenues from its high-worth assets. Even non-controversial proposals with revenue potential are being ignored. Telecom companies have been asking the Government to lease facilities on the MSEB network or through water supply veins to carry voice and data.</p><p>This could generate good income. But there has been no response from the Government. "For a cabinet split on caste, party and regional lines, all these are too progressive even to consider," admits a senior BJP member.</p><p>Of course, there is some consolation in the fact that Maharashtra is not as badly placed as some other states. But given the Government's penchant for grandiose schemes, the ground is certainly slipping. Like the classic Lewis Caroll scenario, it will take all the running it can do for the Government to stay in the same place. To get anywhere, it will have to run twice as fast. <br></p><div id="tab-link-wrapper-plugin"><div class="authors__container"><div class="authors__by"><div class="authlable">Published By: </div><div class="authdetaisl">AtMigration </div></div><div class="published__on"><div class="authlable">Published On: </div><div class="authdetaisl">Aug 24, 1998</div></div></div><div class="sendros">--- ENDS ---</div></div></div>

The BJP-Sena Government's desperate populist programmes drain the exchequer of precious revenue and push the state close to a debt trap.

India Today

Perilously perched - India Today

BJP-Sena Government's populist programmes push Maharashtra close to a debt trap

Perilously perched

At Davos, a session moderated by India Today Group Vice-Chairperson and Executive Editor-in-Chief Kalli Purie brought together leading economist Gita Gopinath, Union Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw, Bharti Chairman Sunil Bharti Mittal, and IKEA Group CEO Juvencio Maeztu Herrera to decode India’s journey towards becoming the world’s third-largest economy.

India Today Group at Davos

Can India become the world’s third-largest economy?

European Parliament suspends work on EU-US trade deal after Trump's repeated Greenland comments at Davos

Donald Trump

EU Parliament halts work on US trade deal after Trump's Greenland remarks at Davos

IND vs NZ, 1st T20I: Suryakumar Yadav showed signs of returning to form, becoming the third-fastest Indian to 9,000 T20 runs with a fluent 32 off 22 balls against New Zealand on Wednesday in Nagpur.

Suryakumar Yadav

Suryakumar Yadav shows signs of form, becomes 3rd fastest Indian to 9000 T20 runs

Prince Harry rejected claims that journalists were close to his social circle and said the articles in question involved unlawful information gathering, including voicemail hacking and deception, which he described as a “horrible experience” and “commercialising” his private life.

Prince Harry

Prince Harry says Daily Mail made Meghan’s life absolute misery in court testimony

A Zomato delivery rider named Dev saved a puppy from traffic and the video has over 1.1 million views. 

puppy

Zomato delivery rider’s mid-shift rescue gives a lost puppy a name and home

Play Time!

Davos 2026

PM Modi

India vs New Zealand Live

T20 World Cup

Deepinder Goyal

Border 2

Dhurandhar

Virat Kohli

JEE Main

Maneka Gandhi

Jana Nayagan

Jaipur Literature Festival

WPL 2026

AR Rahman

Budget

United States President Donald Trump, who addressed the World Economic Forum in Davos, said that he loves Europe, but it's not heading in the right direction.

I love Europe, but it's not heading in right direction: Trump at Davos

In this Special Report, we focus on the retirement of veteran NASA astronaut Sunita Williams after an illustrious 27-year career. Speaking in New Delhi, Williams described her visit to India as a 'homecoming', reflecting on her deep personal ties to the country where her father was born. During an interactive session, she shared profound life lessons from her time aboard the International Space Station, noting, 'Every person I know is there. Every animal, every plant, everything we know is there, and we're all on this one planet.' Williams, who completed three missions and set multiple human spaceflight records, emphasized how viewing Earth from orbit changes one's perception of global differences. The retired astronaut also met with the family of late fellow astronaut Kalpana Chawla during her stay in the national capital. The programme highlights her historic contributions to space exploration and her reflections on humanity's shared home.

Sunita Williams: Being In India Is Homecoming

Sunita Williams retires from Nasa after 27 years, calls India visit a 'homecoming'

This report highlights a major embarrassment for Pakistan's Defence Minister, Khawaja Asif, who inaugurated an unauthorised Pizza Hut outlet in his constituency of Sialkot.

Khwaja Asif Inaugurates Fake Pizza Hut

Khawaja Asif faces ridicule after inaugurating fake Pizza Hut outlet in Sialkot

In this India Today special report, anchor Aishwarya and correspondent Pranay Upadhyay discuss a security scare involving Donald Trump’s aircraft. Air Force One was forced to return to Joint Base Andrews shortly after take-off due to a technical snag in the electrical unit. Pranay Upadhyay noted, 'The security team of President Donald Trump did not want to take any chance with the President's aircraft,' leading to the decision to switch planes. Trump, who was en route to Davos, Switzerland, had to board a backup aircraft to continue his journey. The report highlights that the current VC-25A Boeing 747-200B has been in service since 1990 and is approximately 35 years old. While the aircraft is heavily modified and maintained, a new replacement is not expected until 2027. The return was described as a precautionary measure following the discovery of the minor electrical fault by the crew.

Donald Trumps Air Force One Scare: Technical Snag Forces Return

Donald Trump's Air Force One forced to return to base after technical snag

In an exclusive interview with India Today’s Bhavna Agarwal, actor Sophie Turner was joined by her co-star Archie Madekwe, who spoke about their love for India, RRR and more. 

Sophie Turner India Today Exclusive on India, RRR, Steal. Credit: Prime Video

Download App

Subscribe to India Today Print + Digital. Your First Month Is On Us. ₹299/month thereafter. Cancel anytime.

BJP-Sena Government's populist programmes push Maharashtra close to a debt trap

The BJP-Sena Government's desperate populist programmes drain the exchequer of precious revenue and push the state close to a debt trap.

PUBLICATIONS

TELEVISION

EVENTS

RADIO

GAMING

USEFUL LINKS

PRINTING

WELFARE

DISTRIBUTION

SYNDICATIONS

WEBSITES

EDUCATION