Butchers of Sopore and Birmingham

Nine years of calm before icy storm

Kashmir turns crimson with blood of Pandits

AN UN-ISLAMIC KIDNAPPING AND CHAOS IN THE VALLEY

The illusion of azaadi and Kashmir’s historic deception

How Pak's terror policy evolved in Kashmir

Birth of social media jihadists, death of Article-370

Operation Sindoor: When Indian missiles rained on Pak terror parade

<div class='ite_mg_banner ads__container'><div class='it_mg_bnrBox'><div class='ite_bnr_cont'><div class='ite_cont_dtl'> <h4>Subscribe to India Today Print + Digital. Your First Month Is On Us. <span class='bold_text'> ₹299/month</span> thereafter. Cancel anytime.</h4><a href='https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.dev?url=https%3A%2F%2Fsubscriptions.intoday.in%2Findiatoday%3Futm_source%3Dtop-web-banner ' class='ite_subscribe_btn origin_conscent_url' target='_blank'>SUBSCRIBE</a></div></div></div></div>

US Election coverage

India

World

NewsMo

Fact Check

Programmes

Match Schedule

Teams

Player Stats

Match Report

LIVE SCORES

<div class="itg-mosimage"><amp-img src="https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.dev?url=https%3A%2F%2Fakm-img-a-in.tosshub.com%2Fsites%2Fmedia2%2Findiatoday%2Fimages%2Fstories%2F1998September%2Foffice-1_082112120724.jpg" alt="" height="425" width="650" class="" layout="responsive"></amp-img><p>The government of Atal Bihari Vajpayee has earned the reputation of being a somersault artiste. It turned halfway back on a special import duty within days of putting it in the budget proposals and swallowed back a threat to raise petrol prices.<br><br>Last week the Government beat its own record of "rolling back" its actions when it had to reappoint M.K. Bezbaruah as the enforcement director, 26 days after transferring him to the Delhi Government by a cabinet order. The reappointment of the high-profile Enforcement Directorate (ED) chief did not come about because of a change of heart, as in the case of the import duty rollback, but following a sharp rebuke from the Supreme Court.<br><br>The Government surely had a right to transfer an officer. But in exercising the right, it badly erred on explaining the motives and in proving that these were not arbitrary. The apex court found the Government's reasoning unconvincing enough to rap the knuckles of Solicitor-General of India Santosh Hegde, accusing his client, the Government, of "misleading the court".<br><br>The three-judge bench comprising Justice S.P. Bharucha, Justice G.T. Nanavati and Justice B.N. Kirpal was so irked by the Government's slipshod defence of Bezbaruah's transfer that it did not let off Hegde when he said that the Centre had decided to revoke the transfer order. The judges forced the solicitor-general to file a statement in this regard.</p><div class="itg-mosimage"><amp-img src="https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.dev?url=https%3A%2F%2Fakm-img-a-in.tosshub.com%2Fsites%2Fmedia2%2Findiatoday%2Fimages%2Fstories%2F1998September%2Foffices_082212094611.jpg" alt="" height="425" width="650" class="" layout="responsive"></amp-img><div class="clicktoenlarge"><a href="#" target="_blank" rel="dofollow">Click here to Enlarge</a></div></div></p><p>The Government deserved the judicial reprimand for the convoluted reasonings behind Bezbaruah's transfer, submitted in an affidavit before the court. The affidavit was given by a director in the Department of Personnel which is under the direct charge of the prime minister. According to the Personnel Department's explanation, the need to transfer Bezbaruah arose after July 21, 1998, when, "in pursuance of the directions of this Hon'ble Court", the Government decided to upgrade the post of the enforcement director to the level of special secretary.</p><p>This is exactly where the bureaucracy had led the Prime Minister's Office up the garden path. If only the Personnel Department had followed the court's direction, it would have found replacement for Bezbaruah in an official of the required rank from the 400-odd officials serving the Government. In fact, on the advice of legal experts Vajpayee had directed the Personnel Department and the Cabinet Secretariat to temporarily hand over the charge of the ED to Bhure Lal, secretary to the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC), who made headlines in the '80s in the same post. </p><p>Lal, who is currently an additional secretary-rank officer, fulfills the Supreme Court-ordained requirement for the job. In addition, it would have met the court's other directive that the investigative agencies should be under the superintendence of the CVC. But the prime minister's move was sabotaged by senior officers, perhaps because Lal had acquired in his earlier stint an uncompromising image. </p><p>His appointment would have brought back to life some of the "dead" prosecutions involving the business-bureaucrat nexus. In its judgement of December 18 last year, the Supreme Court directed the upgradation of the post to the level of additional secretary, thus disqualifying Bezbaruah whose present rank is that of a joint secretary, a notch below the eligibility mark. </p><div class="itg-mosimage"><amp-img src="https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.dev?url=https%3A%2F%2Fakm-img-a-in.tosshub.com%2Fsites%2Fmedia2%2Findiatoday%2Fimages%2Fstories%2F1998September%2Foffice-3_082112120724.jpg" alt="" height="425" width="650" class="" layout="responsive"></amp-img>Mutual mess-up: Vajpayee and Advani are unable to control bureaucratic pulls</div></p><p>However, this direction did not come in isolation. It also enjoined upon the Government the need to first make the post of the central vigilance commissioner statutory and then to leave the task of selecting the enforcement director to a panel comprising the CVC, the home secretary and the revenue secretary. The July 21 decision to "upgrade" the post had therefore put the cart before the horse because neither was the CVC a statutory authority then nor was Bezbaruah's successor selected by the panel outlined by the court.<br><br>The affidavit took a further beating for naively taking liberties with official documents that had been presented earlier before the court, for tailoring facts to suit its argument. Before delivering its judgement of December 18 on restructuring investigative agencies like the CBI and the ED, the court had obtained the opinion of an Independent Review Committee (IRC). Following Bezbaruah's transfer, Anil Divan, "friend of the court" in a related case, submitted that the transfer order was not even consistent with the IRC's recommendation.<br><br>While attempting to rebut this allegation, the affidavit said that the Government had steered close enough to the recommendations of the IRC which had cautioned against "external pressure" on the investigative agencies but had never put the transfer of personnel in charge of investigation out of bounds for the executive.<br></p><table><tbody><tr><td><div align="center"><b>Verdict Afterwards</b><br></div><b>ITC:</b> Over $100 m FERA violation case against tobacco major ITC in 1996 has not led to conviction.<br><b>Shaw Wallace: </b>FERA violation cases against liquor baron Manu Chhabria hanging fire as no attempt has been made to extradite him.<br><b>Chandraswami:</b> Bezbaruah inherited the FERA case against the godman, but not an inch of progress so far.<br><b>Prabhakar Rao:</b> The main accused in the Rs 133 crore urea scam has been let off the hook for lack of evidence. <br></td></tr></tbody></table></p><p>The judges were naturally aghast after reading these lines, for the IRC recommendation clearly states that for "premature transfer" of the enforcement director, the "selection committee headed by the central vigilance commissioner" must make suitable recommendations to the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet. It is this distortion of facts that drew the judges' remark that the Government was misleading the court.<br><br>The initiative to transfer Bezbaruah came from the Home Ministry under L.K. Advani, the controlling authority for the Arunachal Pradesh, Goa, Mizoram and Union Territories cadre of IAS officers to which he belongs. The affidavit submitted that the Delhi Government had requested the Centre to release Bezbaruah on August 11, and the Home Ministry complied with the request post haste on August 13.<br><br>It is obvious that the bureaucracy took both Vajpayee and Advani for a ride, keeping them in the dark about the complex motivations and illegalities behind a seemingly innocent executive decision to transfer an officer. Bezbaruah, occasionally projected by the media as a man of steel, however, is far from extraordinary in his ED tenure.<br><br>In his two years and nine months as ED chief, longer than any of his predecessors, he could not close any of the cases he had started - be it the case of ITC, Chandraswami or Shaw Wallace - but has hogged the limelight by charging full-tilt at Ashok Jain, a high-profile media baron. And that too without framing charges. Bezbaruah's disappearance from the ED would not have created a ripple if bureaucrats had not messed it up.<br></p><div id="tab-link-wrapper-plugin"><div class="authors__container"><div class="authors__by"><div class="authlable">Published By: </div><div class="authdetaisl">AtMigration </div></div><div class="published__on"><div class="authlable">Published On: </div><div class="authdetaisl">Sep 21, 1998</div></div></div><div class="sendros">--- ENDS ---</div></div></div>

nation

Nation

<div class="itg-mosimage"><div class="itgimage"><img  title=""  class="" alt="" src="https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.dev?url=https%3A%2F%2Fakm-img-a-in.tosshub.com%2Fsites%2Fmedia2%2Findiatoday%2Fimages%2Fstories%2F1998September%2Foffice-1_082112120724.jpg" loading="lazy" /></div><p>The government of Atal Bihari Vajpayee has earned the reputation of being a somersault artiste. It turned halfway back on a special import duty within days of putting it in the budget proposals and swallowed back a threat to raise petrol prices.<br><br>Last week the Government beat its own record of "rolling back" its actions when it had to reappoint M.K. Bezbaruah as the enforcement director, 26 days after transferring him to the Delhi Government by a cabinet order. The reappointment of the high-profile Enforcement Directorate (ED) chief did not come about because of a change of heart, as in the case of the import duty rollback, but following a sharp rebuke from the Supreme Court.<br><br>The Government surely had a right to transfer an officer. But in exercising the right, it badly erred on explaining the motives and in proving that these were not arbitrary. The apex court found the Government's reasoning unconvincing enough to rap the knuckles of Solicitor-General of India Santosh Hegde, accusing his client, the Government, of "misleading the court".<br><br>The three-judge bench comprising Justice S.P. Bharucha, Justice G.T. Nanavati and Justice B.N. Kirpal was so irked by the Government's slipshod defence of Bezbaruah's transfer that it did not let off Hegde when he said that the Centre had decided to revoke the transfer order. The judges forced the solicitor-general to file a statement in this regard.</p><div class="itg-mosimage"><div class="itgimage"><img  title=""  class="" alt="" src="https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.dev?url=https%3A%2F%2Fakm-img-a-in.tosshub.com%2Fsites%2Fmedia2%2Findiatoday%2Fimages%2Fstories%2F1998September%2Foffices_082212094611.jpg" loading="lazy" /></div><div class="clicktoenlarge" style="width:200px;margin-right:15px text-align:center" valign="bottom"><a href="#" onclick="javascript:window.open('https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.dev?url=https%3A%2F%2Fakm-img-a-in.tosshub.com%2Fsites%2Fmedia2%2Findiatoday%2Fimages%2Fstories%2F1998September%2Fofficel_082212094611.jpg','window','status=no,resize=yes,toolbar=no,scrollbars=yes,width=821,height=862'); return false;" rel="dofollow">Click here to Enlarge</a></div></div></p><p>The Government deserved the judicial reprimand for the convoluted reasonings behind Bezbaruah's transfer, submitted in an affidavit before the court. The affidavit was given by a director in the Department of Personnel which is under the direct charge of the prime minister. According to the Personnel Department's explanation, the need to transfer Bezbaruah arose after July 21, 1998, when, "in pursuance of the directions of this Hon'ble Court", the Government decided to upgrade the post of the enforcement director to the level of special secretary.</p><p>This is exactly where the bureaucracy had led the Prime Minister's Office up the garden path. If only the Personnel Department had followed the court's direction, it would have found replacement for Bezbaruah in an official of the required rank from the 400-odd officials serving the Government. In fact, on the advice of legal experts Vajpayee had directed the Personnel Department and the Cabinet Secretariat to temporarily hand over the charge of the ED to Bhure Lal, secretary to the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC), who made headlines in the '80s in the same post. </p><p>Lal, who is currently an additional secretary-rank officer, fulfills the Supreme Court-ordained requirement for the job. In addition, it would have met the court's other directive that the investigative agencies should be under the superintendence of the CVC. But the prime minister's move was sabotaged by senior officers, perhaps because Lal had acquired in his earlier stint an uncompromising image. </p><p>His appointment would have brought back to life some of the "dead" prosecutions involving the business-bureaucrat nexus. In its judgement of December 18 last year, the Supreme Court directed the upgradation of the post to the level of additional secretary, thus disqualifying Bezbaruah whose present rank is that of a joint secretary, a notch below the eligibility mark. </p><div class="itg-mosimage"><div class="itgimage"><img  title=""  class="" alt="" src="https://ancillary-proxy.atarimworker.dev?url=https%3A%2F%2Fakm-img-a-in.tosshub.com%2Fsites%2Fmedia2%2Findiatoday%2Fimages%2Fstories%2F1998September%2Foffice-3_082112120724.jpg" loading="lazy" /></div>Mutual mess-up: Vajpayee and Advani are unable to control bureaucratic pulls</div></p><p>However, this direction did not come in isolation. It also enjoined upon the Government the need to first make the post of the central vigilance commissioner statutory and then to leave the task of selecting the enforcement director to a panel comprising the CVC, the home secretary and the revenue secretary. The July 21 decision to "upgrade" the post had therefore put the cart before the horse because neither was the CVC a statutory authority then nor was Bezbaruah's successor selected by the panel outlined by the court.<br><br>The affidavit took a further beating for naively taking liberties with official documents that had been presented earlier before the court, for tailoring facts to suit its argument. Before delivering its judgement of December 18 on restructuring investigative agencies like the CBI and the ED, the court had obtained the opinion of an Independent Review Committee (IRC). Following Bezbaruah's transfer, Anil Divan, "friend of the court" in a related case, submitted that the transfer order was not even consistent with the IRC's recommendation.<br><br>While attempting to rebut this allegation, the affidavit said that the Government had steered close enough to the recommendations of the IRC which had cautioned against "external pressure" on the investigative agencies but had never put the transfer of personnel in charge of investigation out of bounds for the executive.<br></p><table style="margin-left: 8px;" align="right" border="1" cellpadding="3" cellspacing="3" height="165" width="229"><tbody><tr><td scope="" style="background-color: rgb(229, 229, 229);" dir="" id="" align="" lang="" valign="" xml:lang=""><div align="center"><b style="color: rgb(204, 0, 0);">Verdict Afterwards</b><br></div><b>ITC:</b> Over $100 m FERA violation case against tobacco major ITC in 1996 has not led to conviction.<br><b>Shaw Wallace: </b>FERA violation cases against liquor baron Manu Chhabria hanging fire as no attempt has been made to extradite him.<br><b>Chandraswami:</b> Bezbaruah inherited the FERA case against the godman, but not an inch of progress so far.<br><b>Prabhakar Rao:</b> The main accused in the Rs 133 crore urea scam has been let off the hook for lack of evidence. <br></td></tr></tbody></table></p><p>The judges were naturally aghast after reading these lines, for the IRC recommendation clearly states that for "premature transfer" of the enforcement director, the "selection committee headed by the central vigilance commissioner" must make suitable recommendations to the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet. It is this distortion of facts that drew the judges' remark that the Government was misleading the court.<br><br>The initiative to transfer Bezbaruah came from the Home Ministry under L.K. Advani, the controlling authority for the Arunachal Pradesh, Goa, Mizoram and Union Territories cadre of IAS officers to which he belongs. The affidavit submitted that the Delhi Government had requested the Centre to release Bezbaruah on August 11, and the Home Ministry complied with the request post haste on August 13.<br><br>It is obvious that the bureaucracy took both Vajpayee and Advani for a ride, keeping them in the dark about the complex motivations and illegalities behind a seemingly innocent executive decision to transfer an officer. Bezbaruah, occasionally projected by the media as a man of steel, however, is far from extraordinary in his ED tenure.<br><br>In his two years and nine months as ED chief, longer than any of his predecessors, he could not close any of the cases he had started - be it the case of ITC, Chandraswami or Shaw Wallace - but has hogged the limelight by charging full-tilt at Ashok Jain, a high-profile media baron. And that too without framing charges. Bezbaruah's disappearance from the ED would not have created a ripple if bureaucrats had not messed it up.<br></p><div id="tab-link-wrapper-plugin"><div class="authors__container"><div class="authors__by"><div class="authlable">Published By: </div><div class="authdetaisl">AtMigration </div></div><div class="published__on"><div class="authlable">Published On: </div><div class="authdetaisl">Sep 21, 1998</div></div></div><div class="sendros">--- ENDS ---</div></div></div>

Bezbaruah's reinstatement following a court order shows that the BJP Government is unable to cope with an intransigent and incompetent bureaucracy.

India Today

A quick rollback to office - India Today

ED chief reinstatement shows government unable to cope with intransigent bureaucracy

A quick rollback to office

Aryna Sabalenka powered into her fourth straight Australian Open quarter-final while Coco Gauff and Carlos Alcaraz also advanced with composed performances. In contrast, Daniil Medvedev suffered a shock exit as Alcaraz set up a quarter-final clash with Alex de Minaur.

Aryna Sabalenka, Carlos Alcaraz

Aryna Sabalenka shatters Novak Djokovic’s feat, Carlos Alcaraz, Coco Gauff into quarters

In his 130th episode of Mann Ki Baat, the first address of 2026, the prime minister said quality must become the defining identity of Indian manufacturing.

Mann Ki Baat

Mann ki Baat: PM urges ‘zero compromise’ on quality to build developed India

A Bengaluru resident has gone viral after sharing the story behind her distinctive surname, revealing her family's conscious decision to avoid social labels. 

bengaluru woman surname

Meet Vipra Bangalore, a woman whose surname is her city. Here's why

India made a couple of changes as they look to wrap up the five-match T20I series against New Zealand, bringing back Jasprit Bumrah and Ravi Bishnoi for the third T20I in Guwahati on Sunday. Mystery spinner Varun Chakravarthy and left-arm pacer Arshdeep Singh were rested as part of workload management.

Jasprit Bumrah, Arshdeep Singh

3rd T20I: Bumrah, Bishnoi return as India rest Varun Chakravarthy, Arshdeep

The Padma Awards 2026 have been announced. Dharmendra has been honoured with Padma Vibhushan, while Alka Yagnik and Mammootty received Padma Bhushan. Prosenjit Chatterjee, R Madhavan and Satish Shah are recipients of Padma Shri for contribution to Indian cinema and music.

Dharmendra,Mammootty,Alka Yagnik

Padma Vibhushan for Dharmendra; Mammootty, Alka Yagnik, receive Padma Bhushan

Play Time!

Donald Trump

T20 World Cup

Tejashwi Yadav

Border 2

Tariffs

Iran

PM Modi

Greenland

Jana Nayagan

WPL 2026

Budget 2026

Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s election rally in poll-bound Kerala on Thursday saw a warm and light-hearted moment when he paused his speech to acknowledge a young child in the crowd holding up his picture, drawing loud applause. Modi asked the boy to hand over the photograph, write his home address on the back, and promised to write to him personally, directing SPG personnel to handle the picture carefully as a token of the child’s affection. 

PM Modi's Kerala  rally.

You’ll get tired beta: PM’s warm moment with child holding his pic at Kerala rally

 Amidst inclement weather and heavy snowfall, a team of Udhampur police rescued 12 individuals, including women and children, who were stranded at Chochru Galla in the upper ridges of the Basantgarh area.

Udhampur Police Rescue 12 People Stranded In Heavy Snow

Udhampur police rescue 12 people stranded in heavy snowfall in J&K's Basantgarh

Ajith Kumar's fans took the celebrations too seriously as they burst crackers inside a theatre hall during Mankatha screening. The film re-released in South India on January 23.

Ajith Mankatha celebrations

Watch: Ajith's fans burst crackers for Mankantha intro scene inside auditorium

In an exclusive interview with India Today TV Consulting Editor Rajdeep Sardesai at Davos, Somalia's Deputy Prime Minister Salah Ahmed Jama spoke in fluent Hindi and slammed Donald Trump for his remarks and recalled his student days in India. 

Download App

Subscribe to India Today Print + Digital. Your First Month Is On Us. ₹299/month thereafter. Cancel anytime.

ED chief reinstatement shows government unable to cope with intransigent bureaucracy

Bezbaruah's reinstatement following a court order shows that the BJP Government is unable to cope with an intransigent and incompetent bureaucracy.

PUBLICATIONS

TELEVISION

EVENTS

RADIO

GAMING

USEFUL LINKS

PRINTING

WELFARE

DISTRIBUTION

SYNDICATIONS

WEBSITES

EDUCATION