Dear Pushpas, a trade deal is a duet, not a duel
A bilateral agreement, like the India-US trade deal, isn't about outright victory or defeat. There are gives and takes, and deals within deals.
After months of suspense, the deal or a lookalike of a deal has been done. We never thought the Indo-US deal was a simple slash-and-dash. Well, Donald Trump made it look like so, even though months of negotiations went into it. From a punishing 50% (his favourite 25% reciprocal + 25% Russian-oil penalty) down to a breezy 18%. The fine print (or lack thereof) emerges like a reluctant guest at the wedding ceremony of his ex.
Trump, ever the showman, trumpeted on Truth Social that, effective immediately, reciprocal tariffs would drop from 25% to 18% before Prime Minister Modi could announce it to his 1.4 billion people. Just like it happened during the Sindoor ceasefire. He said India had supposedly committed to halting Russian oil buys altogether. So we assumed the extra 25% punitive slap for Russian crude vanishes. He said India was pivoting to Uncle Sam's barrels drawn from Venezuela's oil fields. He even tossed in a jaw-dropping $500 billion pledge for US energy, tech, agriculture, coal, and "many other products," plus India slashing its own tariffs and non-tariff barriers to zero. Zero! As in nada, zilch, goose egg on duties for American goods flooding our shores.
Modi, true to form, kept it cautious on X: "Delighted that Made in India products will now have a reduced tariff of 18%. Big thanks to President Trump on behalf of the 1.4 billion people of India for this wonderful announcement." No mention of oil embargoes, no $500 billion shopping bill, no zero-tariff utopia. Just gratitude for the tariff trim and a nod to mutual bonhomie. Measured, modest, masterful at dodging diplomatic dynamite. That's Donald's good friend, Modi Classic.
So, let's slice this onion. The core specifics. Confirmed: US tariffs on Indian exports now sit at 18% overall (reciprocal lowered + punitive axed), effective immediately, according to White House whispers to reporters. This levels us up against Asian peers: Vietnam and Thailand hover 19–40%, Pakistan at 19%, Bangladesh at 20% while India edges ahead. Trade is a margin's game and even 1% means a lot of dollars. Exporters in gems, jewellery, apparel, textiles, and pharma are popping champagne; stocks like gems and jewellery firms sparkled. The Nifty jumped 3% on the relief rally. It's a genuine win for "Make in India" competitiveness, no sarcasm there.
But the devil is in the details. Trump's $500 billion "BUY AMERICAN" bonanza is unconfirmed by any Indian official. Could just be Trump hyperbole, the kind where "billions and billions" means "we'll buy more, eventually, maybe." Indian side talks targeted increases in US energy and farm goods, but nothing near half a trillion. A sudden full stop on Russian oil would disrupt refineries, spike inflation, and hobble growth. India is unlikely to slam the door overnight; expect a gradual pivot, already underway thanks to prior sanctions.
Now, let us come to "zero tariffs and non-tariff barriers." Trump claims it; Modi doesn't echo it. Sensitive sectors like agriculture (dairy, poultry, rice) remain protected fortresses. The US farm lobby dreams of soybeans and almonds flooding in, but expect quotas, selective cuts, not total surrender. What India will certainly go for are mini deals within the deal. Some agri access (ethanol, apples, walnuts, etc.), more US energy buys, but no blanket zeroing that would frazzle our farmers.
The "Narender Surrender Squad" is wailing that we've sold our souls for soybeans; the "Jhukega Nahin Saala Pushpas" pretend we've out-Trumped Trump. Both miss the moot point: deals are duets, not duels. Give and Take, not Give or Take. India gives a firmer farewell to discounted Russian crude (already waning), some market openings for US goodies. We take tariff relief that could juice exports by billions, ease rupee pressure (already in progress), boost jobs in an export-oriented industry battling uncertainty for months. No full capitulation, no fairy-tale free trade. Just pragmatic pro quo.
In global give-and-take, purity is for poets, not policymakers. Trump gets his "end the Ukraine war" oil leverage brag (hyperbolic, but good optics). Modi gets export oxygen out of an economic asphyxiation. The $500B, if it materialises even halfway, great; if it's Trumpian tall-tale territory, still no loss, tariff cut stands. Russian oil halt will be phased, pragmatic, not panic-button. And if the Ukraine war ends midway, consider it a breeze.
The bottom line is that in this bilateral bazaar: You give a little crude loyalty, take a massive tariff haircut. You concede some barriers, gain some edge. It's not surrender; it's savvy. Not capitulation; but calculation. A win-win wrapped in diplomatic duct tape. Thank you, Sergei Gor. So next time the nation navel-gazes over negotiations, remember that in the art of the deal, you gotta give some to take some. Yes, India compromised and cheers to compromise. It's the only tariff that ever truly pays dividends.
After months of suspense, the deal or a lookalike of a deal has been done. We never thought the Indo-US deal was a simple slash-and-dash. Well, Donald Trump made it look like so, even though months of negotiations went into it. From a punishing 50% (his favourite 25% reciprocal + 25% Russian-oil penalty) down to a breezy 18%. The fine print (or lack thereof) emerges like a reluctant guest at the wedding ceremony of his ex.
Trump, ever the showman, trumpeted on Truth Social that, effective immediately, reciprocal tariffs would drop from 25% to 18% before Prime Minister Modi could announce it to his 1.4 billion people. Just like it happened during the Sindoor ceasefire. He said India had supposedly committed to halting Russian oil buys altogether. So we assumed the extra 25% punitive slap for Russian crude vanishes. He said India was pivoting to Uncle Sam's barrels drawn from Venezuela's oil fields. He even tossed in a jaw-dropping $500 billion pledge for US energy, tech, agriculture, coal, and "many other products," plus India slashing its own tariffs and non-tariff barriers to zero. Zero! As in nada, zilch, goose egg on duties for American goods flooding our shores.
Modi, true to form, kept it cautious on X: "Delighted that Made in India products will now have a reduced tariff of 18%. Big thanks to President Trump on behalf of the 1.4 billion people of India for this wonderful announcement." No mention of oil embargoes, no $500 billion shopping bill, no zero-tariff utopia. Just gratitude for the tariff trim and a nod to mutual bonhomie. Measured, modest, masterful at dodging diplomatic dynamite. That's Donald's good friend, Modi Classic.
So, let's slice this onion. The core specifics. Confirmed: US tariffs on Indian exports now sit at 18% overall (reciprocal lowered + punitive axed), effective immediately, according to White House whispers to reporters. This levels us up against Asian peers: Vietnam and Thailand hover 19–40%, Pakistan at 19%, Bangladesh at 20% while India edges ahead. Trade is a margin's game and even 1% means a lot of dollars. Exporters in gems, jewellery, apparel, textiles, and pharma are popping champagne; stocks like gems and jewellery firms sparkled. The Nifty jumped 3% on the relief rally. It's a genuine win for "Make in India" competitiveness, no sarcasm there.
But the devil is in the details. Trump's $500 billion "BUY AMERICAN" bonanza is unconfirmed by any Indian official. Could just be Trump hyperbole, the kind where "billions and billions" means "we'll buy more, eventually, maybe." Indian side talks targeted increases in US energy and farm goods, but nothing near half a trillion. A sudden full stop on Russian oil would disrupt refineries, spike inflation, and hobble growth. India is unlikely to slam the door overnight; expect a gradual pivot, already underway thanks to prior sanctions.
Now, let us come to "zero tariffs and non-tariff barriers." Trump claims it; Modi doesn't echo it. Sensitive sectors like agriculture (dairy, poultry, rice) remain protected fortresses. The US farm lobby dreams of soybeans and almonds flooding in, but expect quotas, selective cuts, not total surrender. What India will certainly go for are mini deals within the deal. Some agri access (ethanol, apples, walnuts, etc.), more US energy buys, but no blanket zeroing that would frazzle our farmers.
The "Narender Surrender Squad" is wailing that we've sold our souls for soybeans; the "Jhukega Nahin Saala Pushpas" pretend we've out-Trumped Trump. Both miss the moot point: deals are duets, not duels. Give and Take, not Give or Take. India gives a firmer farewell to discounted Russian crude (already waning), some market openings for US goodies. We take tariff relief that could juice exports by billions, ease rupee pressure (already in progress), boost jobs in an export-oriented industry battling uncertainty for months. No full capitulation, no fairy-tale free trade. Just pragmatic pro quo.
In global give-and-take, purity is for poets, not policymakers. Trump gets his "end the Ukraine war" oil leverage brag (hyperbolic, but good optics). Modi gets export oxygen out of an economic asphyxiation. The $500B, if it materialises even halfway, great; if it's Trumpian tall-tale territory, still no loss, tariff cut stands. Russian oil halt will be phased, pragmatic, not panic-button. And if the Ukraine war ends midway, consider it a breeze.
The bottom line is that in this bilateral bazaar: You give a little crude loyalty, take a massive tariff haircut. You concede some barriers, gain some edge. It's not surrender; it's savvy. Not capitulation; but calculation. A win-win wrapped in diplomatic duct tape. Thank you, Sergei Gor. So next time the nation navel-gazes over negotiations, remember that in the art of the deal, you gotta give some to take some. Yes, India compromised and cheers to compromise. It's the only tariff that ever truly pays dividends.